VIBE: The Greatest Hip Hop Producer of all time (vote)
- Thread starter DJ Excellence
- Start date
-
beat this! (nov 27-28) signup begins in...
DJ Excellence
ILLIEN
yeah that's part of it, but I remember a lot of kids saying Dilla was top 5 (ever) before he passed away ... of course this is debatable. I voted for Pete because : 1/ he had a longer career 2/ he's been extremely consistent 3/ brought major innovations 4/ always stayed underground , never sold out, a true hip hopper ... dilla had a good career , just not as great as Pete's
DJ Excellence
ILLIEN
please delete blank reply
Peace Out Pat
Beatmaker
ill o.g.
Yeah, but Pete Rock never made an album on his deathbed (yet)
Benny BuKu
BAD NEWS
ill o.g.
ok...so the Mass Appeal section is pretty much garbage. I'll go w/ Swizzie.
Homegrown- I guess I'd have to go w/ Dre out of a lack of options.
Soul Sample and Boom Bap are where the real producers are.
Soul Sample should end w/ Just Blaze and Pete Rock. No disrespect to J Dilla but Pete Rock is better.
And Pete Rock should win but it's not as big a blowout as people might think. Pete Rock just has more classics under his belt...but Just Blaze is a beast.
And of course in the Boom Bap category it will be DJ Premier vs The Rza. And predictably I'm goin w/ The Rza even though I know everyone is gonna say Premo. They are 1&2 in my book anyway so I won't be too upset either way. But if you know me...you know my type a beats are Rza joints!
This was definitely a cool bracket though.
Homegrown- I guess I'd have to go w/ Dre out of a lack of options.
Soul Sample and Boom Bap are where the real producers are.
Soul Sample should end w/ Just Blaze and Pete Rock. No disrespect to J Dilla but Pete Rock is better.
And Pete Rock should win but it's not as big a blowout as people might think. Pete Rock just has more classics under his belt...but Just Blaze is a beast.
And of course in the Boom Bap category it will be DJ Premier vs The Rza. And predictably I'm goin w/ The Rza even though I know everyone is gonna say Premo. They are 1&2 in my book anyway so I won't be too upset either way. But if you know me...you know my type a beats are Rza joints!
This was definitely a cool bracket though.
Is it me, or is alot of dillas stuff offbeat in a way that would make the rest of us go back and use quantize???
Sometimes I feel I must be going mad because though Dilla was a sho nuff talent I dont understand the hype.
Most ,if not all, of Donuts , to me, sounded like unfinished ideas. Which , if so, I can respect it a lil more, but lots of his beats just sound like they are full of mistakes, perhaps thats the appeal, but if so then I should be HUGE if I just turn my quantize off.
I know Im prolly steppin out of line to mention this but am I alone here?
Anyway there is some good educational facts on there about the producers I see, good ish.
Sometimes I feel I must be going mad because though Dilla was a sho nuff talent I dont understand the hype.
Most ,if not all, of Donuts , to me, sounded like unfinished ideas. Which , if so, I can respect it a lil more, but lots of his beats just sound like they are full of mistakes, perhaps thats the appeal, but if so then I should be HUGE if I just turn my quantize off.
I know Im prolly steppin out of line to mention this but am I alone here?
Anyway there is some good educational facts on there about the producers I see, good ish.
DJ Excellence
ILLIEN
ELITE 8 round has begun, go place your votes :
http://www.vibe.com/hiphopproducer
RZA vs DJ Premier
Dr Dre vs The Bomb Squad
Kanye West vs Dilla
The Neptunes vs Timbaland
........
http://www.vibe.com/hiphopproducer
RZA vs DJ Premier
Dr Dre vs The Bomb Squad
Kanye West vs Dilla
The Neptunes vs Timbaland
........
To me, its boiling down to 'who's more popular' rather than 'who's the best'...a couple of those cats shouldn't even be in the ELITE 8 based on being 'the best' imo. But the whole breakdown has been fun watching how it is unfolding.
Benny BuKu
BAD NEWS
ill o.g.
It's too bad it can't end w/ The Rza vs Premo!
DJ Excellence
ILLIEN
Preemo's been the most consistent producer in Hip Hop for a long long time, and all in all I think he's the best ever. I used to like RZA a lot but he never had the same consistency, he made a lot of crap no one can't deny that.
....oh and Dilla beating Pete Rock , that's some BS lol , people need to listen to T.R.O.Y again (I don't think many youngsters know that track tho)
....oh and Dilla beating Pete Rock , that's some BS lol , people need to listen to T.R.O.Y again (I don't think many youngsters know that track tho)
I think alot of cats jumped on the dilla wagon more as a respect thing. Dilla was good, no denying that but he wasn't on PR's level. PR and Premo would be a tough one to me. Thats why I said its starting to look like a popularity contest now.
DJ Excellence
ILLIEN
UNORTHODOX
Father Timeless
Preemo all day
thedreampolice
A backwards poet writes inverse.
Pete Rock IS the greatest producer alive period.
yup, half man, half amazing!