@.calm - Really enjoyed the sapce of the intro. I think if you could have preserved this, perhaps adding similar reverb, compressed room reverb possibly, I think it would have kept that sense of depth to the track and added an extra level. Though I did like the sound design of this and don't have much to say otherwise as it sounded kinda like an 'idea' track.
@Matt-D - These both sounded really well made. Though I think just a hair's touch of reverb to the vocal on the first could have helped it blend more with your instrumental additions. And on the second I think the first drums you were employing, though they were good, did not so much fit the vocals. However, I think the rest from 1:03 fit very well and I enjoyed the intricacies within the patterns you have created. I think the drums are the spotlight piece here.
ALSO *EDIT* Thanks for the feedback brother, appreciate it.
@44Beatzz - I really liked this, great vibe, let it ride out. Blended well and nothing stuck out awry. Replayed twice was a good backround while I wrote the previous two feedbacks. Very chill and I think you did a very good job as a tribute.
@Alejandro - Thank you for the feedback, glad you enjoyed it. As for feedback, agreed with previous feedback as to maybe switching up the arp at points. Possibly letting it wash out with reverb and come back again as something else, or changing it to something else entirely. Or doing something to have it go farther back into the backdrop so it does not stand out so far. I did very much enjoy the bassline patch used in this. The buzzy lead I think could use a little bit of work. But the effects I think were nicely done. The transition-y effects. (Perhaps these could transition to another arp, a change in the arp or something entirely different too!) You've got a base block here for a good beat though if you were to chisel away and smooth out some elements.
@crosstevsky - Agreed about some overcrowding in the first half for sure. The second half however I feel is a bit more refined and I'm happy with it. Also, I don't always make music for vocals. In fact, rarely do I. I try to make music, full and in their entirety as is, whether that means with vocals or not. Though I do believe vocals to be an amazing instrument.
Sometimes I like throwing together some vocal ready tracks though like this one:
[soundcloud]
@crosstevsky - As for your beats; The first one Wild Cat, though I think the mix was well done it was not really my style. A bit too plain is the only way I can explain it.
However the second one; Broomstick I VERY much enjoyed. I thought this was very good, thoroughly enjoyed listening to it. Not sure why the drastic change between the two for me, but I think Broomstick sounds a bit fuller to me and a bit more well thought out and has more interest elements in it. More developed.. Anyways I liked it a lot, thanks.
@DEEZ BEATZ - Thanks for the feedback. Same comment as above. "Agreed about some overcrowding in the first half for sure. The second half however I feel is a bit more refined and I'm happy with it. I appreciate the feedback though." But I will definitely keep this in mind in my next track to will myself to keep the WHOLE piece sounding refined and polished.
@DEEZ BEATZ - As for your beat, I think the drums are great, love them, possibly could add some different fills just to have variation, but they are good. The melodic elements I think are good too (I also enjoyed the bending string-like instrument). Though I think you might have been able to do something to improve the atmospheric elements, ambience, etc.. Some kind of movement to the background harmony, or more blending, or some extra natural ambience (room noise, etc.) just to give everything something to sit in and add a bit more interest or glue for the track. The background harmony that was there did not seem to glue everything to me. ---THINKING ON THIS POINT ACTUALLY, I think this is because the bending instrument seems to be in a space of it's own away from the rest of the atmosphere. Otherwise great beat. Very clean mix.